Never Trump Republicans Need Us to Win

Never Trump Republicans are cute until they forget that if they knew how to beat MAGA, they’d still be Republicans. You represent a slice of voters that essentially doesn’t exist: Republicans who never voted Trump, a rounding error. Excellent critics of Trump from a limited government point of view, essential for a popular front, and the least representative demographic group in America.

Mona Charen gave that rounding error a column at The Bulwark this week.

Democrats who nominate Democratic Socialists, she argued, are handing Republicans a gift. She named names: Claire Valdez, Darializa Avila Chevalier, Melat Kiros, Janeese Lewis George, and Zohran Mamdani, whose smile she says disguises an authoritarian movement. Her case rests on a voter disgusted with Trump but recoverable by his party — if Democrats stop frightening her with socialism. Reject the DSA, the argument runs, or hand Republicans their best distraction from prices, a terrible war, and an immigration crackdown that’s “shocked the conscience.”

Charen is describing a real person. She has the wrong one. The real one is smaller, poorer, younger, and has never heard of the DSA.

G. Elliott Morris ran the numbers this spring. That’s when Trump’s net approval sat at -20.8; the Democratic generic-ballot lead was D+8.1. Pundits treat that 12.7-point gap as a reservoir of persuadable Trump-disapprovers. Morris split it by Republican markers — a 2024 Trump vote, a Republican lean, a conservative self-ID — and found two-thirds isn’t persuadable. That’s Pool 3: Republican-aligned Trump disapprovers, 6.8 percent of registered voters, 89 percent Republican or Republican-leaning, 66 percent who voted Trump in 2024. They dislike him. They’ll vote for his party anyway. This is the electorate Charen is writing to protect. They were never coming.

Do the actual math. Trump won 88 percent of self-identified Republicans in 2016, 94 percent in 2020, 94 percent in 2024 — a twelve-point defection, then six, then six again. A Republican who never once voted for him across three elections is the overlap of those three slivers — even assuming, generously, that it’s the same defectors each time, not three different groups taking turns. Republicans are about a third of the electorate. Multiply it through and the true, three-elections Trump refusenik is worth a few tenths of a percentage point of the country. Not a swing demographic. A rounding error with a really big Substack.

Morris’s Pool 1 — the 3.4 percent of non-aligned, persuadable voters — is the group Democrats can actually move, and it looks nothing like a Bulwark subscriber. No Republican markers, and undecided rather than opposed: 83 percent don’t know how they’d vote. They’re 42.8 percent with no education beyond high school, 37.3 percent under $50,000 household income, nearly a quarter Hispanic, close to a fifth Black, more than a quarter under 30. Almost 40 percent sat out 2024 entirely, and their top concern is prices, at 38 percent, then jobs, at 21 percent. Crime is 3 percent. Immigration and border security together don’t reach double digits.

These are the voters Democrats need. They have never heard of the DSA and wouldn’t give two shits if they had. They just need to make rent.

This is where the popular front stops being a slogan and starts being a trade. Charen isn’t wrong that Trump has alienated a piece of his own coalition — Morris’s data confirms real erosion. She’s wrong about what it’s for. It isn’t a persuasion target. It’s a set of witnesses: Republicans and ex-Republicans who can explain, in language conservatives already trust, how their own coalition built the machinery now gutting the courts and the civil service. They’re credible in rooms where Democrats will never be heard.

Here’s the interesting part. (Took me a while to get there, huh?) You have almost no constituency among actual voters, and an outsized (call it inordinate) amount of power over dorks like us, the people who read thousand-word posts about politics. Charen’s column, and anything The Bulwark runs, will be read by more people than this one ever will. A lot of it is excellent, especially the pieces carrying the byline of Jonathan Cohn, Dean of Health Care Reporters.

Never Trumpers’ sway over the press, over influencers, and over what I call the earlyworms — the fifth or so of the country that follows the news early and tells everyone else what it means — is real, and it’s wildly out of proportion to your electoral representation.

What you can do, for the right-leaning voters still waffling in the room only you can enter, is say the thing only you can say with credibility. A party’s tolerance for a wide range of voices who believe in democracy is the actual measure of its belief in freedom. Uniting against the regime is the best chance anyone has of beating it. Refuse to be divided by people offering nothing but more bigotry and more corruption of the values that are supposed to matter more than any one personality or the cult formed around him.

Because verily I tell you, it’s going to get messier.

And I get it. It’s tough to represent almost no one. And it aches to see your former party with a clarity many of your old colleagues, and still friends, have talked themselves out of. But beating Trump means sitting with something less comfortable than an alliance of the reasonable: it will look like an activated progressive base, which isn’t built to impress lifelong Republican voters.

Think of the 2020 Black Lives Matter protests, some of the largest in American history. Republicans used Fox to spread Trump’s lies that every city in the US was burning and to make it feel like the worst fever dreams of the racists behind all of Stephen Miller’s favorite neo-Nazi manifestos. The centrist assumption is this movement and the slogans around it hurt Democrats when it actually helped them win their first trifecta since 2008.

And political science tells us why.

Bouke Klein Teeselink and Georgios Melios, writing in Political Behavior, found a real jump in Democratic vote share in the counties where protests happened, driven less by turnout than by persuadable voters changing their minds about racial inequality.

If that’s what winning looked like once, this fight may require something louder, ruder, and considerably less interested in checking with you first.

This is why the anti-DSA column is dangerous rather than just wrong. Votes aren’t the leverage here. Narrative is, and the White House needs yours right now.

Marco Rubio’s State Department just published a hundred-page report, Cuba, the Capital of 21st Century Communism. It names Zohran Mamdani, the Democratic Socialists of America, Ben Cohen of Ben & Jerry’s, and radio host Amy Goodman as nodes in a Cuban influence operation supposedly running from the George Floyd protests through the campus Gaza encampments.

Katrina vanden Heuvel likened Rubio to Joseph McCarthy, running a modern loyalty list instead of a hearing room. A handful of DSA primary wins in safe seats is not a national security threat. It’s the pretext the administration is building for the next round of the machinery it already has in place to investigate and prosecute its opposition.

Charen’s column, unintentionally, hands that pretext the sort of hyperlink it desperately wants.

Embracing that myth now, when the fight demands solidarity, is bad strategy before it’s anything else. The same collective-action failure among Republicans that let one man take their party is now repeating itself. It is also, plainly, a lack of patriotism. You don’t have to like every Democratic candidate. You don’t have to vouch for any of them personally.

That’s the whole trade, and it runs one direction. Never Trump Republicans get a coalition big enough to beat the thing they’re more frightened of than they’ve admitted. Democrats get messengers. America gets a chance to keep her Republic.

Get in, hosers. Just don’t try to drive.

Zero trillionaire funding. 100% reader-backed.

To keep our analysis uncompromised and fierce, subscribe to THE FARCE newsletter, join the LOLGOP Studios Patreon, or drop a tip. Free or paid, your support keeps us independent and fearless.

Play our new game—Data Center Invaders!